Overseeing is not signing
Whoever must oversee a machine has the right to the conditions to judge it, not merely to sign for it.
What it says
The rules on artificial intelligence ask for a person who checks the machine. But if that person lacks the time, information and power to say no, the check is a signature.
The article gives the overseer a right, not only a duty: the conditions to truly judge what they must approve.
The words to read it
- Reverse centaur
- The system decides, the human signs. When human oversight becomes a fiction.
On Kairos
- A person is not a rubber stampThe GDPR and the AI Act ask for a person next to the machine. But a person who signs off without being able to understand is not oversight. It is a rubber stamp.
- The system that won't be looked atThe European Commission is talking about "loss of control" and models that are harder and harder to monitor. The legal issue is not power. It is intelligibility: whoever builds a system has to keep it observable.
- Bill the checking, not the draftNew York says hours saved by the tools cannot be billed, while time spent checking can. Maryland takes a lawyer who did not check before its Supreme Court for the first time. The value of our work is moving.
How to cite
Giacomello, M. (2026). Habeas Mentem Charter, art. 7. https://marcogiacomello.com/en/habeas-mentem/carta/7
Short form: Habeas Mentem Charter, art. 7 · Stable address: marcogiacomello.com/en/habeas-mentem/carta/7
Newsletter
Two ideas a week, straight to your inbox
- Notes on law, mind and technology
- Open challenges, before they hit the site
- Early access to new products