No ritual produces understanding
No ritual produces understanding merely by having been performed.
What it says
Ticking a box, signing at the bottom, scrolling to the last line: these are rituals. They produce proof that the gesture happened, not that the person understood.
It is the article against the presumption of understanding. It does not abolish consent: it asks for an honest ritual, one that does not pretend to be a decision.
The words to read it
- Presumption of understanding
- The fiction that informing equals making someone understand.
- Liturgy of consent
- The click as a ritual producing lawfulness without producing understanding. We need an honest ritual.
On Kairos
- The liturgy of consentFreely given, specific, informed, unambiguous. GDPR consent is demanding. The one we give every day is often just a repeated gesture.
- Signing is not understandingThe law assumes that whoever accepts has understood. The data say otherwise. Two studies, one question: who should carry the burden of understanding?
- Fewer banners, more freedom?The EU Council wants fewer cookie banners. Good. But removing a click does not give a choice back: what matters is who decides which questions we stop asking.
How to cite
Giacomello, M. (2026). Habeas Mentem Charter, art. 6. https://marcogiacomello.com/en/habeas-mentem/carta/6
Short form: Habeas Mentem Charter, art. 6 · Stable address: marcogiacomello.com/en/habeas-mentem/carta/6
Newsletter
Two ideas a week, straight to your inbox
- Notes on law, mind and technology
- Open challenges, before they hit the site
- Early access to new products