Marco Giacomello.Mens et opusITWork with me

The average consumer stays. Design enters the courtroom

The Digital Fairness Act came out on 11 November. I had asked which person the lawmaker has in mind when writing “consumer”. The answer is half an answer, and the missing half is the interesting one.

21 November 20263 min read3 sources

On 27 October I wrote that I would look at one thing first in the Digital Fairness Act: which person the lawmaker has in mind when writing “consumer”. On 11 November the Commission presented its proposal. I read it looking for that answer.

There is an answer, and it is half of one.

What changes in the word

The proposal is a regulation, not a directive: if adopted, it will apply identically in every Member State and replace the 2005 directive on unfair commercial practices.

The average consumer stays. It is still the reasonably well-informed, reasonably attentive person. But the recitals add two things. First: assessing that person does not exclude taking cognitive biases into account, as the Court of Justice had already said in 2024. Second: online this person may have a reduced capacity to process information, because there is too much of it or because of limited digital literacy.

Vulnerability widens. Alongside age, disability and credulity comes an open formula: any misfortune or circumstance serious enough to impair judgement. The recitals give examples: financial distress, addictions. It is no longer only a matter of categories. You can be vulnerable because of what is happening to you.

Where it stops

It stops one step short of the point that matters.

Vulnerability remains a condition of the person, even when temporary. The proposal does not say the environment can produce it. Someone tired at eleven at night in front of a countdown has suffered no misfortune: they were reached at the right moment. That case is left to the average consumer, that is, to the original fiction.

And there is a condition: the trader must have been able to foresee that fragility. The text adds that traders are not required to collect more data to find out. That is a sound privacy safeguard. But it leaves a question open: if you measure every click, what can you claim not to have foreseen?

The part I did not expect

On 3 November I wrote that the burden should shift to whoever builds the interface. The proposal does not do that: proof remains a matter for national law.

It does something close, and new. If the claimant brings enough to make an unfair online practice plausible, the court or the authority may order the trader to hand over evidence on how the interface was designed, how it works and what effect it has on people's behaviour. If the trader does not, that may be taken into account, together with the other evidence, in finding the practice unfair.

The text does not mention A/B tests. But evidence of an interface's effect on behaviour is exactly that: the data by which a company knows that a grey button reduces cancellations. It stops being an internal matter and can enter the courtroom. This is not a reversal of the burden of proof. It is an admission that the evidence sits on one side only, and that it has to come out from there.

Alongside this there is a general ban on designing interfaces that deceive or manipulate, and a list of ten practices banned in all circumstances, which the Commission will be able to update. There is a mandatory termination button for anyone who lets people subscribe online. The rule that leaving should be as easy as entering, however, appears only in a recital. I wrote about the switch against addictive design in The right to switch off.

What to watch now

The text now goes to Parliament and Council. Three points will decide how much it is worth.

The first is the formula on serious circumstances: whether it survives, and whether anyone tries to argue that the interface itself can create one. The second is the power to have evidence about design handed over: it is the easiest rule to water down and the most useful to defend. The third is the symmetry between entering and leaving: as long as it sits in a recital, it is a wish.

For those who design digital products the message is already clear, however the negotiation ends. What you know about the effects of your interfaces may become what you are asked to show. It is worth starting to measure understanding, and not only conversion.

The person the lawmaker has in mind is still the average consumer. But the law now grants that person limits in writing, and lets the court make designers open their drawers. That is half the road. The other half is writing that vulnerability can also be built.

Personal reflection, not legal advice.

From the essay to the tool · freeIs it fair? Test your sentence against the Digital Fairness ActWrite a message or an idea and find out whether it is likely to breach the proposal, why, and how to rewrite it.
Newsletter

Two ideas a week, straight to your inbox

  • Notes on law, mind and technology
  • Open challenges, before they hit the site
  • Early access to new products

← All ideas