The proof falls to the designer
When a relevant decision is mediated by a designed environment, it falls to its designer to show, in proportion to the risks, that the conditions of choice did not work against the person.
What it says
This is the inversion that holds the Charter up. Until now the person had to prove their will was flawed. Here whoever designed the environment must show that the conditions of choice did not work against them.
Two limits make it workable: it applies to relevant decisions, and in proportion to the risks. It is not a presumption of guilt: it is a burden on the party who holds the data to discharge it.
The words to read it
- Habeas Mentem
- Everyone’s right to understand, judge and decide in conditions not designed against them. The third step after habeas corpus and habeas data.
- The engineer’s test
- Who benefits from the slope? Can it be said out loud? Can it be reversed? Can it be measured?
On Kairos
- The burden belongs to the designerThe European Commission is expected to present the Digital Fairness Act within days. Before reading the text, I am writing down what I will look for: not another list of bans, but who has to prove that an interface is fair.
- Who is the vulnerable consumer?The Digital Fairness Act is expected on 11 November. The real game is played on one word: vulnerability. And it is a question of design, not of people.
- When manipulation becomes a banThe AI Act bans systems that use subliminal or manipulative techniques to distort people's behaviour. It is an explicit recognition that the ability to decide is something to protect.
How to cite
Giacomello, M. (2026). Habeas Mentem Charter, art. 10. https://marcogiacomello.com/en/habeas-mentem/carta/10
Short form: Habeas Mentem Charter, art. 10 · Stable address: marcogiacomello.com/en/habeas-mentem/carta/10
Newsletter
Two ideas a week, straight to your inbox
- Notes on law, mind and technology
- Open challenges, before they hit the site
- Early access to new products